Survey for 2023 indicates fewer pay increases are coming dreamstime xl 185350557 Pivotal HR Solutions Blog

Survey: Not as Many Employers Planning Base Pay Improvements in 2023 Compared to Previous Years

Explore the changing landscape of base pay improvements in 2023. Unravel insights from Payscale’s latest survey revealing fewer employers plan base pay increments compared to previous years.

In the constantly shifting landscape of today’s global economy, businesses face a myriad of challenges. Among these, one particular aspect stands out due to its undeniable significance and its direct impact on the very core of every organization – payroll management.

Salary structures, encompassing base pay and benefits, lie at the heart of business operations, serving not only as a means of remuneration but also as a powerful tool to attract, engage, and retain talent. In fact, an organization’s approach to base pay often reflects its philosophy towards employee satisfaction and its commitment to financial sustainability.

Within this intricate framework of payroll management, a recent survey by Payscale offers valuable insights that warrant careful consideration. As an authority in the realm of salary data and software, Payscale’s research endeavors provide essential perspective on salary trends and compensation strategies across various industries and regions.

The survey in question unveils a notable shift in employers’ approach towards base pay improvements planned for 2023[1]. In contrast to prior years, fewer employers seem inclined to implement these improvements, a trend that raises critical questions about the economic environment, labor market conditions, and their interplay with organizational payroll strategies.

With the goal of delving deeper into this development and its implications, this article will dissect the data, discuss potential influencing factors, and explore what this could mean for businesses and employees alike in the forthcoming year.

Unpacking the Economic Factors

In the face of uncertainties surrounding the economic status, a noticeable reticence has taken root among employers when considering increasing workers’ wages. The survey indicates a fivefold increase in the number of employers expressing uncertainty about offering base pay increases in 2023. This uncertainty is a significant jump from 3% in 2022 to 15% in 2023, demonstrating the widespread apprehension gripping the industry.

This reluctance to commit to base pay improvements can be traced back to a variety of factors. Notably, there is a perceptible cooling of the labour market which previously displayed a ‘white-hot’ fervor. Alongside this, the looming specter of a potential recession and the lessons learned from liberal spending on payroll in 2021 and 2022 have driven organizations to adopt a more conservative approach.

Moreover, the employee sentiment towards their financial prospects is also rather bleak. Fewer than half of Canadians expressed positivity about their financial situation, according to a recent report by Global News[2]. This apprehension resonates with the cautious approach taken by employers towards base pay improvements.

Zooming in on the Planned Base Pay Increases

While the proportion of employers planning to increase base pay has seen a downturn, there is a silver lining. The Payscale survey suggests that the size of the planned increments is higher than in previous years. This trend indicates a strategic approach among employers, balancing their financial constraints with the need to remain competitive in the talent market.

According to the survey data from nearly 5,000 employers spread across the U.S., Canada, Europe, the Middle East, and Africa, 56% of the companies are planning base pay increases exceeding 3%. This percentage marks an increase from 53% in 2022, 36% in 2021, and 26% in 2020, showing a positive trend. More specifically, the increments planned range from a 3% increase planned by 19% of the companies to more than 5% by 11% of companies.

Interestingly, back in December, a Normandin Beaudry survey[3] predicted a 4.7% increase in average salary budgets for Canada, excluding freezes. The figures from the Payscale survey seem to align with this forecast, indicating a somewhat balanced approach towards payroll management amid economic uncertainties.

Factors Influencing Base Pay Increases

The determination of the exact figure for base wage increase is a complex process, hinged on various interrelated factors. The survey reveals that performance (72%) remains at the forefront of these considerations. However, other critical elements such as market adjustment/talent competition (67%), inflation/cost-of-living (54%), internal pay equity (44%), hot skills (27%), minimum wage increases (18%), tenure (19%), and preparations for pay transparency (18%) also have substantial influence.

Despite being commonly referred to as ‘merit increases,’ base pay increments are closely tied to economic conditions. In light of the high inflation rates and demands for greater pay transparency, the decision-making process for base pay increases has become increasingly intricate. The balance between rewarding individual performance and managing the organization’s financial health is a complex tightrope that HR management needs to walk.

Pay compression, where there is a small difference in pay between employees regardless of their skills or experience, has become a significant issue. With new legislation pushing for greater pay transparency and equity, organizations need to address this issue head-on, adding yet another layer of complexity to payroll management.

The Challenge of Recruitment and Retention

Staffing and recruitment are integral to the growth and success of any organization. Yet, these aspects have been increasingly challenging in recent times. The Payscale report highlights these challenges, with 54% of Canadian employers citing recruitment as their top concern. Pay increase requests, with a significance of 46%, and employee retention, with a relevance of 37%, also emerged as major challenges.

These figures underline the complexity of HR management in the current economic climate. As pay increases are often seen as a tool for attracting and retaining talent, the reduced tendency for base pay improvements in 2023 might have a knock-on effect on recruitment and retention efforts. The interplay of these factors is a critical aspect for industry experts to consider when formulating their HR strategies.

Implications for the Future of Payroll Management

While fewer employers are planning base pay improvements in 2023, it’s crucial to note that those planning increments are doing so at a more significant percentage than previous years[4]. This approach seems to suggest a calculated strategy in response to the current economic uncertainties and changing market conditions.

Balancing the competing needs of maintaining financial stability, attracting and retaining talent, and ensuring equitable pay structures poses a considerable challenge for organizations. It underscores the importance of effective payroll management systems and strategic HR planning.

The shift towards more significant but less frequent base pay increases may be a key trend shaping the future of payroll management. As businesses navigate the uncertainties of the economic landscape, agility and adaptability will be key to success.

Key Takeaways

In a nutshell, the Payscale survey sheds light on the evolving strategies of businesses in relation to base pay improvements amid the turbulent economic climate. The data points towards a strategic shift among employers, opting for more significant but less frequent increments to navigate financial constraints while remaining competitive in the talent market.

However, as the implications of this shift continue to unfold, one thing is clear – payroll management and HR strategies need to remain agile and responsive. Businesses must make informed decisions based on a blend of economic conditions, market trends, and internal factors such as performance and skill sets. As we venture further into 2023, keeping a close eye on these evolving trends will be crucial for industry experts and professionals in the field.


Notes and References

[1] – PayScale Survey 2023.

[2] – Canada Debt Confidence Report. Global News.

[3] – Normandin Beaudry Report 2022.

[4] – HR Reporter. Fewer employers planning base pay improvements in 2023.


Scroll to Top